![]() by Robert Shaw
NEW ENGLAND George Boyd (1873-1941) of Seabrook, New Hampshire was a professional carver who made duck, goose and shorebird decoys as well as miniature birds of many different game species. His shorebirds were sold through the Iver Johnson sporting goods store in Boston in the early years of the twentieth century. Boyd also worked as a shoemaker and created a number of black duck and goose decoys with bodies of canvas tightly stretched and tacked over a wooden slat frame. All of Boyd's birds have distinctive, square head shapes, flattened at the crown, while his floaters have flat bottoms, rounded backs, and relatively long tails. He delineated crisp overall plumage outlines and then daubed in softer feathery patterns with repeated short strokes of his own handmade brushes. Joseph Whiting Lincoln (1859-1938) was a life-long resident of Accord, Massachusetts, a small town south of Boston, where he made a living as a professional decoy carver and handyman. In addition to carving birds, he also worked as a shoemaker, upholsterer and clock repairman, and is said to have been prouder of his prize-winning dahlias than of his decoys. Lincoln carved decoys of virtually every species hunted in New England, including brant, geese, ducks and shorebirds, and also made many miniature decoys he called "toys." His birds are direct and deceptively simple, the work of a consummate Yankee craftsman who was able to capture the essentials of species form and plumage with a remarkable economy of means. A gifted amateur carver and dedicated outdoorsman, Shang Wheeler (1872-1949) lived in Stratford, Connecticut at the mouth of the Housatonic River, and worked as manager of the Connecticut Oyster Farms in nearby Milford from 1912-46. Wheeler gunned over birds made by Albert Davids Laing (1811-1886) for many years and was strongly influenced by his work as well as that of Laing's neighbor, Benjamin Holmes (1843-1912). Laing codified a style of carving peculiar to Stratford, with hollow, two-piece bodies, protruding chests and varied head positions. Wheeler carried the Stratford style into the twentieth century, creating both working birds (including some with solid cork bodies and inset wooden tails) and fancier show birds intended solely for exhibition. (He took the Grand Prize at the first decoy show ever, held in 1923.) NEW ENGLAND SHOREBIRDS Shorebird hunters set out small groups of decoys and then hid behind a sedge grass blind or dune to await their prey. Many called the birds with tin snipe whistles or pursed lips. Shorebirds travel in closely packed flocks and their gregarious nature made them easy marks. The gullible little birds often circled over decoys again and again, allowing hunters multiple shots into the midst of the flock. Dozens or even hundreds of birds could be killed in a short time. Massachusetts' craftsmen created a wider variety of shorebird species and forms than were produced in any other region, including lightweight birds balanced to rock in the sea breezes, birds with attached wings or detachable heads, and birds made of papier mache and cork. The carvers of many Massachusetts decoys have never been identified, but masters such as Charles W. Thomas, Joseph Lincoln, Elmer Crowell, George Boyd, Elisha Burr and Lothrop Holmes are well known to all shorebird connoisseurs. Lothrop Holmes (1824-1899) came from a family of shipbuilders and made his living as a cemetery superintendent in Kingston, Massachusetts, on the state's South Shore, He is remembered today for his merganser and old squaw duck decoys and for his shorebirds. He was an avid gunner who apparently carved only for his own use, and surviving examples of his work are consequently rare. Holmes produced representations of three major shorebird species-yellowlegs, black-bellied plover and ruddy turnstone, the last a great rarity among New England shorebird carvings. Holmes was a masterful painter and the sinuous, stylized lines of his plumage paint patterns perfectly complement the flowing forms of his carvings. A. ELMER CROWELL Elmer Crowell's best work,, was done before 1925 and is unsurpassed for its combination of sculptural power and subtle brush work. Of special note is the preening goose decoy made for Cohasset businessman Harry V. Long in 1917. Long commissioned many pieces from Crowell over the years; this bird and its companion, a spread-winged hissing goose, are arguably Crowell's supreme works. Crowell's paper pattern for the preening goose is in the collection of Heritage Plantation of Sandwich, Massachusetts. LONG ISLAND SHOREBIRDS Unlike any other area of the country, shorebirds are Long Island's dominant decoy form. Curlews, black-bellied and golden plovers, yellowlegs, dowitchers, robin snipe and many other shorebird species frequented the marshes and beaches of Long Island's south shore in great numbers, and the birds were avidly hunted from the Great South Bay to Montauk Point. They were popular home fare all over Long Island and were also a staple of the game stands in New York's Fulton and Washington markets, where they were purchased by city restauranteurs. Long Island was home to a number of the acknowledged masters of the shorebird decoy, including Obediah Verity, Bill Bowman, John Dilley and Thomas Gelston. Verity (poss. 1813-1901) of Seaford, Long Island was a bayman, remembered by his neighbors as a lifelong bachelor who spent his days following the sea-hunting, oystering, clamming, fishing and making decoys for himself and his friends. The Verity clan was extensive, and while this carver's name is known, he has not been positively identified among the six Obediah Veritys who lived in Seaford during the nineteenth century. Verity carved both ducks and shorebirds, all of which have full, rounded solid bodies, s-shaped wing contours, v-shaped primaries carved in low relief, and carved eyes. The backs of his plump shorebirds carry stippled daubs of paint which suggest the light and dark pattern of feathers.
John Dilley is a cipher, little more than a name found on a single box of expertly carved and exquisitely painted shorebird decoys made in the latter decades of the nineteenth century. The box was also marked "Quogue," a town on Long Island's south shore, near Eastport. Since many other birds by the same hand have Long Island provenances, it is assumed that their maker worked nearby, but no more substantial proof exists. Whoever he was, Dilley painted a wider variety of seasonal plumage variations than any other shorebird craftsman. He painted dowitchers, for example, in breeding, eclipse and fall plumage, each rendered with meticulous attention to detail through hundreds of delicate brush strokes. Dilley's paint is highly refined and skillfully controlled, the work of a master of the brush, while the forms he created as his canvases are also careful representations of the species they imitate. Thomas Gelston (1851-1924) was born into a prominent Bay Ridge, Brooklyn family. His parents owned the Fort Hamilton, a seaside resort hotel, and Gelston undoubtedly gunned for ducks and shorebirds in the salt marshes of nearby Sheepshead Bay as a boy. As an adult, he summered in Quogue where he led the life of a independently wealthy gentleman sportsman. He carved brant, black duck, merganser and shorebird decoys for his own use and apparently sold some cork-bodied shorebirds through New York's Abercrombie and Fitch in his later years. Gelston's Hudsonian curlews and yellowlegs are notable for the flowing lines of their lively body forms and their simple but effective paint. The breasts of his shorebirds are speckled with dozens of tiny dabs of paint. THE DELAWARE RIVER John English (1852-1915) was the patriarch of a decoy making family based in Florence, New Jersey. English's influential decoys set the style followed by succeeding generations of upper Delaware River carvers. He added detailed feather paint, carved tail feathers and relief-carved primaries to his hollow-bodied lures, and also occasionally created birds with high or nestled heads to vary the look of a rig. A number of John English's decoys were repainted around 1920 by John Dawson (1889-1959) of Trenton. Dawson's detailed, stylized paint proved a perfect match for English's forms, and these English/Dawson's have long been among the most highly regarded of Delaware River decoys. John Blair, Sr. (1842-1928), a carriage maker and sportsman who supplied vehicles to prominent Philadelphians in the years following the Civil War, was the style setter in the lower Delaware River area. The crisply painted, smooth-bodied decoys that apparently also came out of his shop are more closely related to the New Jersey coastal tradition than to the raised wing carving of the upper Delaware River. Three different grades of related decoys are attributed to the Blair shop, but family members have confirmed that John Blair owned and used only the finest birds associated with his name. These have rounded, hollow bodies that are joined with dowels and weighted with a beveled lead rectangle attached with tiny nails; the heads sit on a raised shelf and have tack eyes. Some of Blair's decoys are carved with their necks extended forward to suggest a swimming bird. NEW JERSEY Early New Jersey carvers developed what has come to be known as the dugout, the state's predominant decoy style. The dugout style was formed by 1850 and remained largely unchanged for a century. Designed for use in the narrow hulled sneak box boats favored by coastal gunners, dugout decoys have small, hollow, two-piece cedar bodies with round bottoms, and upright pine heads which almost invariably face straight forward. The smooth, rounded bodies are made of equal halves of cedar hollowed out with a gouge and laminated together. Like saltwater lures everywhere, the decoys were painted simply and economically, with plumage patterns broadly outlined in solid colors. Harry Vinucksen Shourds (1861-1920) of Tuckerton was New Jersey's
most prolific and influential Nathan Rowley Horner (1881-1942) lived in West Creek, New Jersey, near Tuckerton. Although he was far less prolific than Shourds, Horner consistently produced decoys of the highest quality and refinement. The lines of Horner's carvings are generally sleeker than Shourds', and his paint is more subtle, employing a wider range of colors and techniques, including blending and stippling. In further contrast to Shourds, Horner weighted his floaters with a bevel-edged sheet of lead which he attached to the bottom of the decoys with brass screws. NEW JERSEY SHOREBIRDS While New Jersey's shorebird carvers include such well known figures as Harry V. Shourds, Taylor Johnson and Daniel Lake Leeds, many other equally skilled craftsmen are anonymous. Johnson (1863-1929) of Point Pleasant was a professional carver who made both ducks and shorebirds, while Dan Lake Leeds (1852-1922) of Pleasantville concentrated solely on shorebirds. Their work defines the wide range of the state's shorebird forms. Johnson's quickly but surely carved birds have elongated body profiles and very simple monochromatic paint. Their small heads and long thin bills must have invited breakage. By contrast, Leeds' work is far more careful than Johnson's, with raised-wing carving, split tails and detailed plumage paint patterns with complex lines that bear comparison with the work of Massachusetts's Lothrop Holmes. THE WARD BROTHERS Crisfield had its own decoy making tradition, completely different
from any other part of the Chesapeake Bay. Like other Crisfield
decoy makers, including their father and various members of the
Sterling and Tyler families, the Wards carved solid-bodied lures
with flat bottoms and bold, dramatic After World War II, economic changes and Lem's artistic inclinations led the brothers to focus increasingly on decorative work, made for competitions and mantelpieces. The Wards became major figures in the transition from working decoys to decorative bird carving that took place in the 1950s and '60s. The Ward Foundation, a non-profit institution dedicated to perpetuating the work of the Wards and other American wildfowl carvers and artists, was founded in Salisbury, Maryland in 1968, and Lem was honored as a National Heritage Fellow by the National Endowment for the Humanities, Folk Art Program in 197?. THE SOUTH ATLANTIC The Cobb family owned and operated Virginia's best known hunting
and fishing retreat, located on Cobb Island, Virginia, just off
the Eastern Shore. The Cobbs hosted many prominent visitors over
the years, to whom they supplied fishing tackle, decoys and guide
services as well as outstanding food and accommodations. Nathan
Jr. (c. 1825-1905) is believed to have carved the majority of
the decoys used on Cobb Island, many of which are marked with
a carved N. His output includes geese and brant, a variety of
ducks, and several species of shorebirds. Cobb employed naturally
curved roots and branches gathered from seaside holly trees to
create the animated, twisting necks of his geese and brant decoys,
and carefully fitted carved oak bills through the back of his
shorebirds' heads. In addition to their expressive sculptural
possibilities, both materials were readily available and able
to withstand hard use in the field. Hucks Caines was one of five brothers who lived on an enormous
tract of coastal South Carolina purchased in 1905 by the financier
and statesman Bernard Baruch. Baruch dubbed his 17, 500 acre
purchase Hobcaw Barony and developed it into a private These unique birds have elongated heads and necks nearly as long as their bodies, which are set back over their chests in an undulating double curve that somehow succeeds in both defying and capturing nature. While the most refined of the Caines birds may have been made for the mantelpiece rather than the marsh. the mallard at right, originally in the McCleery collection, is clearly a gunning bird. The decoy's simple, weathered paint and rope line markings attest to its life on the water, while its direct sculptural power elevates it to a category all its own. LOUISIANA Bayou carvers-a rich ethnic mix of Cajuns, French, Germans, Yugoslavians, Italians and other nationalities-brought influences from their native cultures to the art of the decoy. Because they needed only a few decoys at a time, many carvers spent extra time fashioning birds with flamboyant head and body positions, raised wing carving and vivid paint patterns. They fashioned their unusual decoys from the wood of native tupelo gum and bald cypress trees. Both woods approach tropical balsa in their extremely light weights, but unlike balsa they are ideal carving woods, densely grained, durable and resistant to rot. Nicole Vidocavitch (1853-1945), who is widely considered Louisiana's greatest carver, lived in Sunrise for many years, where he worked as a market gunner and as a guide at the Delta Duck Club. The club was frequented by wealthy sportsmen from New Orleans, who provided a ready market for Vidocavitch's decoys. In 1915, a major hurricane decimated Sunrise and the destitute 62 year-old Vidocavitch relocated to New Orleans, where he survived by selling his carvings. His solid-bodied mallard and pintail decoys are carved from cypress roots and have dynamic, elongated forms with relief-carved wings. ONTARIO David K. Nichol (1859-1949) of Eastern Ontario's Smiths Falls was a master carpenter and boatbuilder who added relief carved wings to his meticulously made decoys. He may have been influenced by French Canadian carvings from nearby Quebec, which have the most extravagantly carved surfaces of all North American decoys. MASON'S DECOY FACTORY More a cottage industry than a factory in the modern sense of the term, the Mason company divided labor among its employees to increase production. Apprentices began the process by roughing out decoy bodies on a lathe. Skilled master carvers then added hand carved heads and finished the details of the body before turning their work over the paintshop for final detailing. The Mason factory offered duck, goose and brant decoys as well as shorebirds, crows and doves, all sold by the dozen. It also accepted special orders, lending its style to patterns or models sent in by hunters with particular needs. Mason's ducks were offered in five ascending grades, with prices matching the degree of carving and painting detail. The company's top grade, called Premier, featured hollow two-piece bodies, elaborate bill carving and swirling, stylized paint patterns; a dozen Premiers cost $12 in the early years of this century. ILLINOIS Charles Schoenheider, Sr. (1856-1924) of Peoria was a carpenter
and market gunner who made decoys primarily for his own use.
While he also made a number of floating lures, Schoenheider's
most distinctive works are his standing mallards, pintails and
geese, made for winter shooting near air holes in frozen lakes
and rivers. Made following the same elongated forms as his floaters,
Schoenheider's standing mallards and pintails each balances on
a single cast iron foot. The iron foot could be heated to melt
into the ice, which would quickly refreeze and secure the decoy.
All of Schoenheider's standing ice decoys were painted by Jack
Franks, a Peoria decorator.
MINNESOTA AND WISCONSIN
Enoch Reindahl (b. 1904) of Stoughton, Wisconsin was a conservationist and semi-professional nature photographer whose decoys reflect his life-long love of nature and wild birds. Reindahl was a perfectionist, and his decoys feature carefully carved body and head contours, heads set in reaching, sleeping and turned positions, raised wing carving, and highly detailed comb and feather paint. Reindahl's fastidious attention to detail extends to the eyes of his birds, which he insisted on carving and painting because he did not find glass eyes realistic enough. His article " How to Make Decoys" was published by Field and Stream magazine in 1949, and he coached several younger men, including Ferd and Mandt Homme of Milwaukee, in his techniques. THE WEST COAST Charles Bergman (1856-1946) of Astoria, Oregon was a Finnish-born seaman who carved professionally after his retirement from the boatyards in 1929. He was an avid hunter, and sometime before the shooting of swans was outlawed in 1918, he carved a rig of twelve whistling swan decoys for his own use. The birds have hollow two-piece red cedar bodies and unusual heads and necks made in three pieces. Only two survivors of the rig are known Horace Crandall (1892-1969) of Westwood, in north-central California, was an amateur taxidermist who carved delicate, solid-bodied decoys with raised wings. His highly detailed plumage painting reflects his life-long interest in oil and watercolor painting. Robert Shaw, 435 Longmeadow Drive, Shelburne, VT 05482 Phone 802/985-0737, email: shaw.bob@verizon.net © 2005 Robert Shaw |